Quick answer
Masturbation is far older than any of the rules against it: primatologists trace it back about 40 million years. Many ancient cultures accepted it, while Judaism, Christianity and Islam came to discourage or forbid it, largely because semen was tied to procreation and was believed to be a limited vital essence. From around 1712 until the mid-twentieth century, Western doctors wrongly treated it as a disease that caused weakness, madness and even blindness. Since 1972, when the American Medical Association declared it normal, medicine has regarded it as a healthy part of human sexuality.
There are plenty of articles listing the health benefits of masturbation, including our own. This one asks a different question: why do so many people still feel uneasy about something almost everyone does? The answer lies in ancient ideas about semen, religious rules, an eighteenth-century medical panic and the legends it left behind, including the one every Italian boy has heard: si diventa ciechi.
The short version
- Masturbation is ancient: it probably goes back about 40 million years in our primate ancestors.
- Many ancient cultures were relaxed about it. What worried them was the idea that semen is a limited vital essence.
- Onan, whose name gave us “onanism”, actually practised withdrawal, not masturbation.
- The medical panic is modern. It began with a London pamphlet around 1712 and lasted two centuries, with brutal “cures”.
- The “you’ll go blind” legend grew out of old beliefs that semen came from the head and that losing it harmed the senses.
- Medicine has considered masturbation normal since 1972, but the old fears survive in shame, folklore and “semen retention” culture.
- c. 40 million years agoMasturbation is likely present in the common ancestor of monkeys and apes.
- Ancient EgyptIn one version of the Heliopolis creation myth, Atum creates the first gods through self-pleasure.
- 4th century BCDiogenes the Cynic masturbates openly in the Athenian marketplace.
- 13th centuryThomas Aquinas classes masturbation among the sins against nature.
- c. 1712The London pamphlet Onania launches the medical panic.
- 1760Samuel-Auguste Tissot publishes L’Onanisme, listing blurred vision among the harms.
- 1880sJohn Harvey Kellogg promotes bland diets and harsh physical “cures”.
- 1948 & 1953Kinsey reports that 92% of men and 62% of women have masturbated.
- 1972The American Medical Association declares masturbation normal.
- 1994US Surgeon General Joycelyn Elders is forced out after saying it could be taught.
01Older than humanity
Masturbation did not begin with us. In 2023, anthropologists at University College London compiled reports from nearly 400 sources on primates in the wild and in zoos. They concluded that masturbation was probably already present in the common ancestor of monkeys and apes, including humans, around 40 million years ago.1
The researchers suggest it may even have had an evolutionary purpose in males: it appears more often in species where males compete for mates, where it may improve the odds of conception, and in species with a high burden of sexually transmitted infections, where flushing the genital tract may help.1 Whatever its origins, the point is simple: it is one of the oldest behaviours we have. The shame came much later.
02Gods, philosophers and poets
Many ancient cultures saw masturbation as unremarkable, and at least one saw it as sacred. In the creation story of Heliopolis in ancient Egypt, the god Atum brought the first gods, Shu and Tefnut, into being alone. Some versions of the myth describe the act of creation as spitting or sneezing, others as masturbation, with Atum’s hand representing the female principle within him.2 The universe, in that telling, began with self-pleasure.
In ancient Greece, masturbation was generally treated as a normal outlet and a safety valve against frustration, not a moral crisis.3 The philosopher Diogenes the Cynic, famous for living in a barrel and mocking polite society, was said to have done it openly in the marketplace. His biographer records that, when criticised, he said he wished it were as easy to banish hunger by rubbing the belly.4 In Rome, the poet Martial mocked it as a slave’s substitute for sex, while admitting to it himself.3
03Semen as a precious essence
If the ancients were relaxed about the act, many were anxious about what it spent. Across very different cultures, one idea kept returning: semen is a concentrated, limited vital substance, and losing too much of it weakens the body.
- Greek medicine. Hippocratic writers taught that semen was drawn from throughout the body, including the brain. Centuries later, Leonardo da Vinci copied the idea into his notebooks: “Hippocrates says that the origin of men’s sperm derives from the brain.”5
- Taoist China. Taoist sexual teaching held that semen carries the most jing, the vital essence that, once exhausted, means death. Retaining semen was a foundational practice, believed to send the essence upward to “nourish the brain”.6
- India. Ayurvedic tradition describes semen as the most refined of the body’s seven essential elements, slowly condensed from food. Fear of losing it survives today in South Asia as Dhat syndrome, a recognised culture-bound condition in which men suffer real anxiety, fatigue and low mood from the belief that semen loss is draining their health.7
- The famous ratio. The saying that “forty drops of blood make one drop of semen” is often called ancient Indian wisdom. A 2025 study traced it instead to medieval Arabic medicine, recorded in the work of Ibn Sina (Avicenna), from where it travelled widely through Europe and Asia.8
Hold on to this idea, because it explains almost everything that came later, including the blindness legend, and it is alive today in the “semen retention” corners of the internet.
04Religion and the sin of Onan
Most major religious traditions have rules about sexuality, and many discourage or forbid masturbation. Their reasons differ, and so does the strictness. Here is a brief and, we hope, fair overview.
The story of Onan
The old word for masturbation, onanism, comes from Genesis 38. After his brother Er died, Onan was required by custom to father a child with his brother’s widow, Tamar, so that the line would continue. Knowing the child would not count as his own, “he spilled it on the ground, lest that he should give seed to his brother”, and God struck him dead.
Read closely, Onan’s act was withdrawal during intercourse, not masturbation. Medieval theologians mostly condemned him for what he refused to do, his duty to his brother’s family, rather than for the act itself. Augustine described him as the sort of person who fails to help those in need.9 The link between Onan’s name and solitary sex was made much later, as we will see.
Judaism
Jewish law came to prohibit “wasting seed”, applying the language of the Onan story to masturbation. Reasons given over the centuries include ritual impurity, the medieval physician Maimonides’ belief that excessive emission weakens the body, and, in the mystical tradition, the idea that wasted seed destroys potential life. Orthodox Judaism generally keeps the prohibition; Conservative, Reform and unaffiliated Jews largely do not follow it in practice. Because the sources focus on the emission of semen, female masturbation is not explicitly addressed.10
Christianity
In the thirteenth century, Thomas Aquinas classed “procuring pollution, without any copulation, for the sake of venereal pleasure” among the sins against nature, because it separates sexual pleasure from procreation.11 The Catholic Church still teaches that masturbation is “an intrinsically and gravely disordered action”. The same paragraph of the Catechism adds that, in judging responsibility, one must take into account affective immaturity, the force of habit, anxiety and other psychological or social factors that can lessen or even remove moral blame.12 Protestant churches vary widely, from strict disapproval to treating it as a private matter of conscience.
Italy, with the Church at the centre of daily life, felt this teaching intensely. The eighteenth-century Neapolitan bishop Alfonso Maria de’ Liguori, one of Catholicism’s most influential moral theologians, warned that even touching a girl’s hand, if done for pleasure, was already a step towards “pollution”. In nineteenth-century Lombardy, some seminaries reportedly installed mirrors in bathrooms so that young men could be watched.13
Islam
Islamic scholars also differ. The Shafi‘i and Maliki schools prohibit masturbation, citing Quran 23:5–7, which praises believers who guard their private parts except with their spouses. The Hanafi and Hanbali schools generally prohibit it but allow it as a lesser evil for someone who fears falling into adultery or fornication. Shia scholars treat it as a serious sin.14
Many believers today follow these teachings sincerely, and many others interpret them more loosely. Whatever one’s view, it is worth noting that the scientific findings later in this article are about health, not morality. They do not settle religious questions, and they are not meant to.
05The great panic: when masturbation became a disease
Here is the surprising part. For most of Western history, masturbation was a minor sin, occasionally joked about or mildly frowned upon. It became a terrifying medical threat only in the early eighteenth century.15,9
Around 1712, an anonymous pamphlet appeared in London with the title Onania: or, the Heinous Sin of Self-Pollution, and All Its Frightful Consequences. It blamed masturbation for epilepsy, weak legs, impotence and sickly children, and conveniently sold remedies for those conditions. It was a runaway success: fifteen editions and around 15,000 copies by 1730.16 Historians describe it as quackery that nevertheless became the foundation stone of a serious medical tradition.15
In 1760, the respected Swiss physician Samuel-Auguste Tissot gave the panic scientific prestige with L’Onanisme. Drawing on the old idea of semen as a vital fluid, he called it an “essential oil” whose loss caused a reduction of strength, memory and reason, nervous disorders, gout, headaches and blurred vision.17 Philosophers including Kant and Voltaire repeated his arguments, and for roughly two centuries Western medicine treated masturbation as a debilitating illness.17

The cure was worse than the disease
By the nineteenth century, the fight against “self-abuse” had become an industry. The American doctor John Harvey Kellogg, today remembered for cornflakes, devoted 97 pages of his book Plain Facts for Old and Young to the “secret vice”, listing 39 supposed warning signs. Alongside the preacher Sylvester Graham, of graham crackers, he promoted a bland, meatless diet to calm the passions.3 His other remedies were far darker: bandaged hands, genital cages, electric shocks, circumcision of boys performed without anaesthetic so that the pain would be remembered, and carbolic acid applied to girls’ clitorises.3,18
Others patented restraining belts and alarms, designed trousers and desks that prevented touching, and discouraged girls from riding horses or bicycles.3 The German psychiatrist Richard von Krafft-Ebing, whose Psychopathia Sexualis (1886) shaped European medicine, recommended cauterising the clitoris in severe cases.13 Routine circumcision of newborn boys spread in the United States and Britain partly as a way to prevent masturbation.3
For two hundred years, doctors treated one of the most harmless things a person can do as a disease, and the treatments did real harm.
06“You’ll go blind”: the legend explained
As the surgical “cures” faded, the warnings moved into homes, schools and confessionals. Parents and priests told children that masturbation would make them go blind, grow hair on their palms or stop growing.3 In Italy, generations of boys heard the same warning: si diventa ciechi, you will go blind. Its companion was ti crescono i peli sulle mani, hair will grow on your hands.
The white of the eye
One version told in Italy even explains the mechanism. Semen and the white of the eye were said to be made of the same precious white substance, so every ejaculation used up a little of the eye, until, with enough of it, the eyes would be emptied and sight would fail.
No medical text that we know of puts it quite that way, and it is best understood as folklore. But it is not random. It follows exactly the logic of the ideas above: that semen is a limited vital essence drawn from the head and the body’s most precious substances,5,6 and that losing it damages the senses, as Tissot claimed with his “blurred vision”.17 A white fluid, a white part of the eye, and an ancient belief that seed came from the head: put them together, and the legend almost writes itself.
The hairy-palms warning works differently. It was probably never meant to be believed literally, but to shame: a visible mark that would tell the world what you had been doing. Folklorists still collect both legends today, usually passed between teenagers in locker rooms rather than from doctors.19
For the record: masturbation does not affect your eyes, your palms or your height. There is no biological connection between semen and any part of the eye.
07The turn: from disease to normal behaviour
The panic broke slowly, and science did the breaking.
- 1897: the British physician Havelock Ellis challenged the list of masturbation-induced diseases and concluded that, in moderation, it had no serious harmful effects in healthy people.3
- 1905: Sigmund Freud wrote about masturbation openly, including in childhood, although he remained ambivalent about it in adults.3
- 1948 and 1953: Alfred Kinsey’s surveys reported that 92 percent of American men and 62 percent of women had masturbated. A behaviour that almost everyone shared could hardly be a rare disease.20
- 1968 and 1972: masturbation disappeared as a diagnosable condition from the American psychiatric manual, and the American Medical Association declared it normal.3
- 1994: US Surgeon General Joycelyn Elders said at a UN conference on AIDS that masturbation “is a part of human sexuality” and perhaps should be taught. She was forced to resign days later. The following year, the retailer Good Vibrations declared May National Masturbation Month in her honour.21
The old ideas have not completely gone. The modern “NoFap” and “semen retention” movements promise energy, focus and testosterone from not ejaculating, which is the ancient vital-essence theory with new vocabulary. And the World Health Organization, when it defined compulsive sexual behaviour in 2019, felt the need to state explicitly that distress coming only from moral disapproval does not count as a disorder.22 Centuries of shame still shape how people feel.
08What science says today
Two centuries of medical warnings turned out to be wrong. Modern research finds no link between masturbation and blindness, madness or weakness, and points instead to several benefits. We cover the evidence in detail in The Benefits of Masturbation: What the Science Actually Says. In brief:
- It is the norm. In Britain’s national survey, 77.5 percent of men and 40.3 percent of women had masturbated in the past month.23
- It helps many people relax and sleep. More than half of adults in one survey said orgasm through masturbation improved their sleep.24
- It does not drain testosterone. Levels did not fall after masturbation to orgasm in laboratory tests.25 The popular claim that abstinence boosts it by 45 percent comes from a study that was later retracted.26
- It is linked to prostate health. Men who ejaculated 21 or more times a month had about a 20 percent lower risk of prostate cancer.27
- It can improve partnered sex. Guided masturbation is one of the best-supported treatments for women who struggle to reach orgasm.28
The tradition Tissot started was not entirely without consequence, though. Shame is still the most common side effect of masturbation, and it is entirely man-made.
09Historical myths and the facts
Curiosity, good taste and no taboos
BentBox is a marketplace for independent creators, photographers and collectors who believe sexuality deserves to be shown with care and honesty. Every creator is verified, and every piece of content is consensual.
Join BentBox For collectors →FAQFrequently asked questions
Why did people say masturbation makes you go blind?
The blindness warning grew out of very old beliefs that semen is a limited vital essence drawn from the head and the body's most precious substances, so that losing it weakens the body and the senses. In 1760 the Swiss physician Samuel-Auguste Tissot listed blurred vision among the effects of masturbation, and later generations of parents, teachers and priests turned this into the simple threat that you will go blind. In Italy one folk version claims that semen and the white of the eye are the same substance. None of this has any basis: masturbation does not affect eyesight.
What is onanism and who was Onan?
Onanism is an old word for masturbation, taken from Onan in Genesis 38. Onan was required to father a child with his dead brother's widow and instead spilled his seed on the ground, which describes withdrawal during intercourse rather than masturbation. Medieval theologians mostly condemned him for refusing his duty to his brother's family. His name was attached to masturbation mainly in the eighteenth century, through the London pamphlet Onania.
Why do religions forbid masturbation?
Reasons vary. Catholic teaching holds that sexual pleasure belongs within marital intercourse open to procreation and calls masturbation a gravely disordered act, while noting that immaturity, habit and anxiety can reduce moral blame. Orthodox Judaism prohibits wasting seed, Islamic schools range from prohibition to allowing it as a lesser evil than fornication, and some Eastern traditions value retaining semen as vital energy. Many believers interpret these teachings strictly and many others more loosely.
When did doctors stop treating masturbation as a disease?
Gradually, over the twentieth century. Havelock Ellis challenged the supposed diseases in 1897, Alfred Kinsey's surveys showed in 1948 and 1953 that most men and women masturbated, masturbation disappeared as a diagnosable condition from the American psychiatric manual in 1968, and the American Medical Association declared it normal in 1972.
Was masturbation accepted in the ancient world?
Often, yes. In ancient Egypt one version of the Heliopolis creation myth describes the god Atum creating the first gods through masturbation. In ancient Greece it was generally treated as a normal outlet, and the philosopher Diogenes the Cynic was said to masturbate openly in the marketplace. What ancient medicine worried about was not the act but the loss of semen, which many cultures believed to be a precious, limited vital essence.
What did John Harvey Kellogg have to do with masturbation?
Kellogg, the American doctor remembered for cornflakes, was one of the most aggressive anti-masturbation campaigners of the nineteenth century. His book Plain Facts for Old and Young devoted 97 pages to the 'secret vice', and he recommended bland meatless diets, bandaged hands, genital cages, circumcision of boys without anaesthetic and carbolic acid applied to girls' clitorises. The popular claim that cornflakes were invented specifically to stop masturbation is a simplification: they fitted a diet he believed would calm sexual passion.
What is Dhat syndrome?
Dhat syndrome is a culture-bound condition described mainly in South Asia, in which men experience anxiety, fatigue, weakness and low mood because they believe that losing semen, through masturbation, nocturnal emission or urine, is draining their health. It reflects the long-standing belief, found in Ayurvedic tradition, that semen is the most refined and precious substance in the body. It is treated with reassurance, sex education and, where needed, treatment for anxiety or depression.
Is semen retention, or NoFap, a new idea?
No. The belief that keeping semen preserves strength and vitality is one of the oldest ideas in the history of sexuality. Taoist teaching held that semen carries jing, the vital essence, and recommended retaining it; Ayurvedic tradition sees semen as the body's most precious element; and the saying that forty drops of blood make one drop of semen goes back at least to medieval Arabic medicine. Modern research does not support the idea that retaining semen boosts testosterone or health.
Did Italians really believe masturbation causes blindness?
The warning 'si diventa ciechi', you will go blind, was very widely used in Italy by parents, teachers and priests, along with 'ti crescono i peli sulle mani', hair will grow on your hands. One folk version explains it by claiming that semen and the white of the eye are the same precious substance, so ejaculation slowly uses up the eye. These were warnings meant to discourage the habit, rooted in Catholic teaching and in eighteenth-century medicine, and they have no biological basis.
SOURCESReferences
- Matilda Brindle et al.. The evolution of masturbation is associated with postcopulatory selection and pathogen avoidance in primates. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 2023.
- Wikipedia. Ancient Egyptian creation myths. Wikimedia Foundation.
- Wikipedia. History of masturbation. Wikimedia Foundation.
- Diogenes Laërtius, trans. R. D. Hicks. Lives of Eminent Philosophers, Book VI: Diogenes. Perseus Digital Library.
- Leonardo da Vinci, ed. Jean Paul Richter. The Notebooks of Leonardo da Vinci, note 1491. Project Gutenberg edition.
- Wikipedia. Taoist sexual practices. Wikimedia Foundation.
- Om Prakash and Sujita Kumar Kar. Dhat Syndrome: A Review and Update. Journal of Psychosexual Health, 2019.
- Diederik F. Janssen. “Forty Drops of Blood Make One Drop of Semen”: A Well-Traveled Aphorism. Journal of Psychosexual Health, 2025.
- First Things. Onan in History. First Things.
- My Jewish Learning. What Does Judaism Say About Masturbation?. My Jewish Learning.
- Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologiae, II-II, Question 154, Article 11. Christian Classics Ethereal Library.
- Holy See. Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 2352. Libreria Editrice Vaticana.
- Focus. Masturbazione: perché è ancora un tabù?. Focus.it.
- Wikipedia. Islam and masturbation. Wikimedia Foundation.
- Jesse Singal (via History News Network). Why We're Scared of Masturbation. History News Network.
- Wikipedia. Onania: or, the Heinous Sin of Self-Pollution. Wikimedia Foundation.
- Wikipedia. Samuel-Auguste Tissot. Wikimedia Foundation.
- John Harvey Kellogg. Plain Facts for Old and Young (1881 edition; the harshest remedies were added in later editions). Project Gutenberg.
- USC Digital Folklore Archives. Urban Legend: Masturbation Leads to Blindness. University of Southern California.
- Alfred C. Kinsey et al.. Sexual Behavior in the Human Male (1948) and Sexual Behavior in the Human Female (1953). Summary via Wikipedia, Kinsey Reports.
- Wikipedia. Joycelyn Elders. Wikimedia Foundation.
- World Health Organization. ICD-11 6C72: Compulsive sexual behaviour disorder. WHO.
- Nicole Fischer, Mark Kozák, Cynthia A. Graham, Soazig Clifton, Catherine H. Mercer and Kirstin R. Mitchell. Trends in masturbation prevalence and associated factors: Findings from the British National Surveys of Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles. The Journal of Sex Research, 2025.
- Michele Lastella, Cathy O'Mullan, Jessica L. Paterson and Amy C. Reynolds. Sex and Sleep: Perceptions of Sex as a Sleep Promoting Behavior in the General Adult Population. Frontiers in Public Health, 2019.
- Michael S. Exton, Tillmann H. C. Krüger, Norbert Bursch et al.. Endocrine response to masturbation-induced orgasm in healthy men following a 3-week sexual abstinence. World Journal of Urology, 2001.
- Mo Jiang, Jiang Xin, Qiang Zou and Jie-Wen Shen. A research on the relationship between ejaculation and serum testosterone level in men (retracted). Journal of Zhejiang University Science, 2003.
- Jennifer R. Rider et al.. Ejaculation Frequency and Risk of Prostate Cancer: Updated Results with an Additional Decade of Follow-up. European Urology, 2016.
- Erica Marchand. Psychological and Behavioral Treatment of Female Orgasmic Disorder. Sexual Medicine Reviews, 2021.
This article is for general education about the history of sexuality. Descriptions of religious teachings are summaries for context, not theological guidance. For health questions, see our science guide or speak to a doctor.
